Corporate reductionists argue that sales boils down to one thing and one thing only: incentives.
Without these, they argue, a salesforce might not try to achieve the goals set for them. Or achieve a bare minimum necessary to keep and maintain their jobs. For organizations that need a constant pipeline of warm leads this behavior is not ideal.
Then, to set achievable appointment settings goals for the sales team– managers must align incentives so that the sales team is locked in healthy competition.
Win-Win.
Problem solved, right?
Well, no, actually this is a recipe for disaster and most sales managers never catch up unless this blows up in their face.
The Appointment Setting Incentive System Has a Problem
Most smart people always game the systems, especially incentive systems, in their favor. And unfortunately for organizations, the sales team is made up of exceptional people.
So, how do you model their behavior in favor of the organization and set goals that do not hamper the organization?
First, let’s dive into the deep end to see where things can go wrong.
Wells-Fargo: Eight is Great
Gr-Eight was the motto of Wells Fargo- basically, the sales people had to sell 8 bundles to a single customer or face the consequences of missing targets. These were : –
- Reduced compensation and bonuses.
- Pressure from branch managers and supervisors.
- Possible demotion.
- Threats of termination.
- Increasing sales shortfalls being carried into subsequent targets.
Do you know what the employees did under this steady supply of threats and duress?
Thousands of Wells-Fargo employees resorted to aggressive selling and when that did not work– opened false accounts under their customers’ names. Millions of fraudulent accounts were opened to meet their quotas over a 10-year period.
Employees responded to sales pressure by:
- Opening bank accounts without customer consent.
- Applying for credit cards without authorization.
- Creating fake email addresses to enroll customers in online banking.
- Transferring money between accounts to make newly opened accounts appear funded.
- Selling customers products they neither wanted nor needed.
And when they did get caught- around 6k employees were let go and the SEC launched an investigation into the organization, culminating in a settlement that cost Wells Fargo $3 billion in 2020.
Yeah, setting up S.M.A.R.T goals was never going to save this disaster.
The aggressive behavior of managers, and the employees willingness to go this far to save their jobs- without anyone blowing the whistle on it- became the recipe of such catastrophe.
The People Problem of Appointment Setting
Sometimes people just don’t want to buy what you’re selling.
Why did the Wells-Fargo 8 product per household need to: –
- Be so aggressive?
- Need gaming the system?
Through Occam’s razor one can deduce it was that their customer did not want to buy the products and did not see the merit of buying.
This statement, then stands true: A brand or organization cannot generate sufficient demand by volume alone- it has to create that demand by changing people’s perception. Which is a long-term goal and one that does not respond to aggression very kindly.
Solution to: How to set achievable appointment setting goals for your sales team
There is a 3 step framework that you can use. But don’t worry, we won’t use the word orthogonally so that your head blows up. This framework is simple and based on things you can realistically achieve even without a multi-million dollar budget.
The framework is something like this:
- Incentives influence behaviour, but don’t guarantee productive behaviour.
- Sales targets cannot manufacture customer demand.
- Demand creation and appointment setting operate on different timescales.
See how each step is connected- these are problem statements that you arrive at when you, as Charlie Munger puts it, inverse the problem of good appointment setting practices.
For every framework- we will give you what setting an achievable goal looks like in practice.
Incentives influence behaviour, but don’t guarantee productive behaviour.
First, aggressive behaviour while setting incentives may cause teams to game the system. For example, if you are rewarding appointments held- they might get people to sit for the appointment but not convert, in turn promising a reward.
If it is for opportunities converted, they might convert someone who is not the ICP.
If it is for ICP only converts then they might target only easy-to-convert accounts that don’t help the company long-term.
The point is that incentives can be gamed.
So to set an incentive system the game cannot be aligned against the customer, and the salesforce- it must satisfy three conditions:-
- Empowering the salesforce: means giving people the ability to make good decisions, rather than forcing them to pursue a predetermined number regardless of circumstances.
- Serving the customer: rewarding relevance, suitability and genuine business value, rather than merely getting someone to agree to a meeting.
- Serving the organization: ensuring that these activities contribute to profitable growth, pipeline development and sustainable customer relationships. (this is where most organization optimize for)
For example, in tech, this doesn’t just mean giving out incentives if an enterprise account is closed but also any accounts that show potential for growth. I.e., they show signs of increasing headcount, closing more rounds, or showing more usage per user than what is normal.
Sales targets cannot manufacture customer demand.
Demand creation is vital (again, very literally) to the sales process. Without understanding or knowing that what your product does or your customers want is moot.
Sometimes the buyers don’t want to buy what you’re selling but sales managers try to solve this problem by fabricating demand. Volume upon volume of cold calls and emails to fix the problem.
And in the end, all they are left with is an empty pipeline that hasn’t converted in a year.
A lot of nos and a few maybes.
Everyone has seen this playout in their offices- almost as if this were a GTA-style simulation.
And the manager then blames their team for failure.
No- this failure is systematic. There is no demand, no demand means no need for your solution. And no need means little to no conversions.
To solve this, appointment setters must work on two fronts: –
- The first touch BDR call- teams should also try to listen to the buyers problems than pitching like they’re from a rap group.
- The marketing-sales nurture track- usually this means creation of assets that solve buyer pain points (Sounds easy but it’s not.)
- Re-touching them, this time with specific ideas.
- A nurture track
- Sales Call
Demand creation and appointment setting operate on different timescales.
A buyer who doesn’t need your solution today might need it six months from now. But a salesperson who is evaluated every month cannot afford to wait six months for that buyer to convert.
And therein lies the problem.
Managers expect short-term results from activities that sometimes require long-term investment.
This is why appointment-setting goals must distinguish between buyers who are ready for a conversation and buyers who are still discovering their problems.
Your sales team cannot accelerate every buyer’s purchasing decision. But they can improve the chances of being considered when that decision is made.
So, instead of measuring every salesperson against the same number of appointments, account for the opportunities available to them.
A Simple Framework for Setting Achievable Appointment Goals
Before assigning targets, answer five questions:
- Capacity: How many prospects can your team realistically engage every month?
- Conversion: What percentage of those prospects agree to an appointment?
- Qualification: How many appointments actually meet your ICP and qualification criteria?
- Demand: How many prospects are ready to buy, and how many require nurturing?
- Performance: How many qualified appointments eventually become genuine sales opportunities?
Let’s say your team engages 200 prospects, books 20 appointments, and only 8 qualify.
Increasing the target to 30 appointments doesn’t necessarily solve anything. You might simply end up with more unqualified meetings.
Instead, understand why the other 12 didn’t qualify. Was it poor targeting, weak qualification, or buyers who weren’t ready?
This is where achievable goals begin.
We’ve created a simple Appointment Setting Goal Calculator that helps you work backwards from your team’s capacity, conversion rates, and qualification performance.
Use it to estimate realistic targets rather than inventing numbers your salespeople must somehow achieve.




